aquatic weed control
Kentucky Pesticide Safety Education Program
Cattails along a stream

Printer Friendly Version button

Questions?

Contact

Dr. Lee Townsend
Dept. of Entomology
University of Kentucky
859-257-7455
ltownsen@uky.edu

Adapted from North Central Regional Extension Publication No. 241, Carole A. Lembi, Aquatic Weed Specialist, Purdue University and Aquatic Pest Control, University of California Leaflet 2961


Managing Aquatic Weeds

Preventative Control

Proper site selection, design, and construction of ponds are important factors in preventive control of aquatic weeds. Shallow water at the margins provides an ideal habitat for emergent plants. Banks should be sloped steeply so that very little water is less than 2 to 3 feet deep.

Proper design and construction of ditches and channels makes weed control easier in the future. If the banks are leveled and smoothed, hard-to-reach places will be eliminated. Lining canals will help to alleviate water weed problems, too.

Mechanical Control

Mechanical control may be needed to manage severe waterweed infestations. Aquatic herbicides may not be an option if the water is used for livestock, drinking, or fish. Hand-pulling weeds or dredging the pond may be used, if practical.

Motor-driven underwater weed cutters are available and can be used for the control of such plants as water-lilies and watermilfoil. Some mowers simply cut the weeds loose beneath the water surface. Aquatic weed harvesters collect weeds for removal.

Disposal of harvested weeds can be a problem. Most mechanical control methods fragment weeds. Many weed species can spread and reproduce from these pieces. Mechanical control is usually slower and more expensive than the use of herbicides. Underwater weed cutting must be done continuously during the summer and usually represents a long-term financial investment.

Other types of habitat manipulation include riprapping shorelines and anchoring screens (e.g., Aquascreen®) or black plastic sheets in the bottom sediments to prevent establishment of rooted plants.

Aquashade in pond
Aquashade® (photo: tricountyfs.com)

Dyes such as Aquashade® inhibit light penetration. They can be applied along the shoreline and will mix throughout the body of water within about 24 hours. The dye intercepts light normally used for photosynthesis by underwater plants. A minimum effective concentration must be maintained for effective control.

Cultural Control and Habitat Alteration

Cultural control and habitat alteration can be effective in controlling aquatic weeds. The drawdown technique, lowering the water over the winter, can be very effective. Exposure of the sediments in the shallow areas of a lake or pond to alternate freezing and thawing action will kill the underground rhizomes of many aquatic weeds (the majority of aquatic weeds are perennial and come from rhizomes).

Lake that has ben drawn down
Photo: J. Lennon

Drawdown has been quite successful against Eurasian watermilfoil and waterlilies, but the degree of control depends somewhat upon the severity of the winter. There are several advantages to a winter drawdown in addition to weed control. As the sediment dries, it is compacted, thereby increasing the depth of shallow areas.

Many aquatic plants or their seeds are carried into a pond by wind, birds, stocking fish, people, etc. These plants infest a pond only if the water conditions are just right. Their success usually means that nutrients are entering the pond from runoff or stream inflow.

How to help prevent serious weed infestations:

    Do not fertilize ponds. Most waters in Kentucky are sufficiently rich in plankton and other food organisms.

    Maintain a good sod and grass cover around your pond. This will help prevent runoff and erosion. Do not fertilize the turf directly around the pond.

    Livestock will increase turbidity and fertility and tear down the banks. Limit their access to ponds only to avoid of extreme heat stress. Otherwise, fence the pond and water animals outside the fence.

    Check septic tanks for possible leakage or seepage into the pond. Locate new septic drainage fields so that the nutrient-rich effluent will not reach your pond.

    Do not permit runoff from chicken coops, feedlots, etc., to enter your pond. If this kind of runoff is occurring upstream from your pond, you should check with your county Board of Health to see if anything can be done about it.

All of these measures will help prevent weed growth, particularly in new ponds. In older ponds these measures may only aid in reducing infestations of floating plants such as algae and duckweed.

Aeration has been publicized as another method of weed control. Although it is definitely beneficial for fish life and can help prevent fish kills, there is no evidence that aeration inhibits weed growth.

Biological Controls

Biological control is the reduction or removal of a plant using grass carp or other species. It became legal to release the sterile triploid form of the grass carp or white amur (Ctenopharyngodon idella) in Kentucky in 1986. This fish feeds on aquatic vegetation with little effect on other fish in the pond and cannot reproduce. The non-triploid form is illegal to use in Kentucky.

Grass carp
Grass carp (photo: finfarm.com)

Larger grass carp are less effective at plant control so periodic re-stocking is necessary. These fish can escape ponds through overflows so preventive barriers are needed. They prefer some aquatic plant species but may not effectively control others. Over-stocking may require removal of extra carp after the vegetation is controlled.

The grass carp is the only one of five carp species found in Kentucky that eats aquatic vegetation. When stocking your pond be sure to use grass carp; the other species will not work and can harm other fish in the pond. More information on grass carp is available at http://fw.ky.gov/Fish/Pages/Farm-Pond_Management-Biological-Treatment.aspx.

Chemical Controls

Herbicides can be used to control aquatic weeds. Those used primarily to control algae may be called algicides, even though they also kill other aquatic plants. Used properly, aquatic herbicides can control vegetation without harming fish or other aquatic life.

Applying aquatic chemical control
Photo: mainelakes.org

Aquatic herbicides must be labeled for that use by the Environmental Protection Agency and registered with the Kentucky Department of Agriculture. They vary in their weed control spectrum, specific application sites, and application methods. After a weed has been correctly identified, read the labels carefully before buying and using any product. Most have restrictions that may prevent their use on particular bodies of water. Also, be sure to include secondary water uses (i.e., swimming, livestock watering and irrigation) when selecting products.

Thermometer
Ideal water temperature (photo: lochnesswatergardens.com)

Most aquatic weeds begin growing in early spring when water temperatures reach 55°F to 60°F. The spring months (March, April, May), when water temperatures are between 70° and 80°F, are an ideal time to apply herbicides to control aquatic weeds. At this time weeds are small and easier to control than during the summer; in addition, dissolved oxygen levels in the water are usually higher.

Aquatic herbicides are not toxic to fish when applied according to label directions. Failure to follow label directions can result in fish kills. Plants killed by the herbicides often decompose rapidly. This process consumes dissolved oxygen, reducing the amount available to fish. Fish kills can occur if the dissolved oxygen concentration drops too low. Observe treated water for 1 week, have emergency aeration equipment available in case oxygen depletion problems occur.

Treating the pond with herbicides during the hot summer months is risky because dissolved oxygen concentrations tend to be low and weed biomass tends to be high. Treat only 1/4 to 1/3 of the total surface acreage of a pond at one time to minimize the risk of herbicide-induced dissolved oxygen depletions. However, even partial pond treatments can be risky during the summer in ponds that routinely have low dissolved oxygen levels. In addition, some herbicides are not labeled for partial pond treatments.

Multiple application of products with the same mode of action can result in herbicide-resistant plants. Rotate among herbicides with different modes of action and use cultural and biological control when possible.

Herbicide Formulations

Aquatic herbicides generally are available in sprayable or granular formulations.

Sprayable Formulations

Sprayable formulations must be mixed with water and applied so that they disperse evenly. Examples include:

  • AS - aqueous solution – liquid formulation with water as solvent
  • SP - soluble powders dissolve and form true solutions in water.
  • WP - wettable powders
  • DF – dry flowable
  • WDG – water dispersible granule
  • EC - emulsifiable concentrates form milky white "oil-in-water" emulsions

 

Granular Formulations

Granular herbicide

• G - granular formulations are small clay-based pellets that carry the active ingredient on or in the product. They are usually distributed by some sort of slinger-spreader and sink to the bottom. Slow-release granules or pellets release the pesticide active ingredient over an extended period of time.

Granules are used primarily to control algae or submersed weeds. They sink to the bottom and work about the same manner as bottom soil treatments. Application rates for granules are given as amount per unit of surface area or as a concentration in ppm. They must be broadcast evenly over the water surface for best results.

Advantages to granular formulations include

  • treatment is confined to the bottom are where submersed weeds are
  • slow-release formulations can provide extended control
  • low concentrations of herbicides can be used
  • toxicity to fish may be reduced

 

Application

A mechanical sprayer or spreader and boat are needed to adequately treat large areas. Sprayable herbicide formulations can be applied with hand-held or mechanical pressurized sprayers or with a boat bailer. Injecting the chemical near the outboard motor propwash will help to disperse it. Submersed plant treatments from boats often require the use of weighted trailing hoses to distribute the herbicide directly on the target plants.

Hand-operated or mechanical rotary spreaders can be used to apply granular or pelleted formulations. Soluble crystals should be dissolved in water and sprayed over the pond. While not ideal, the required amount can be placed in burlap bags and dragged behind a boat or suspended in the water near an aerator until the herbicide dissolves.

Adding a registered aquatic adjuvant (usually a surfactant) to some foliar applied herbicides (e.g., diquat, glyphosate) will help them wet and penetrate the foliage. Use a registered aquatic adjuvant that is recommended by the manufacturer according to the label directions. Using adjuvants to treat submersed weeds is usually not recommended.

What You Need to Know Before Using a Chemical

The most important considerations before buying and applying a herbicide for aquatic weed control are:

Identify the weed correctly. The types of weeds controlled can vary greatly among herbicides. Selecting the wrong produce can result in a control failure. Identification help can be obtained from your county Extension Service.

Restrictions on water use. Although most aquatic herbicides break down readily and rapidly in water and pose no threat to human or animal health, there are waiting periods on the use of water treated with most herbicides. These restrictions--usually on fishing, swimming, domestic use, livestock watering or irrigation--dictate which herbicides will be appropriate for your pond or lake. Always check the herbicide label for restrictions.

Dosage. Most aquatic herbicide labels give dosages on the basis of acre-feet (volume measurement). Acre-feet is calculated by multiplying the surface area by the average depth. For example, a pond with a surface acreage of l/2 acre and an average depth of 4 feet contains (4 feet x 1/2 acre) = 2 acre-feet. Check the herbicide label for the amount to apply per acre-foot.

Timing. Late spring is usually the best time to apply aquatic herbicides because the plants are young actively growing. That is when they are most susceptible to herbicides. Do not wait until late summer to treat. By then the vegetation is usually extensive and thick and the water is is warm and still. Killing all vegetation at once under these conditions could seriously deplete the water of its oxygen and cause a fish kill. If you must treat this late in the summer, treat only a portion of the weed growth at a time.

Temperature. Aquatic weeds are not affected by herbicides when the water is too cold. The water temperature should be in the 60's °F., preferably the upper 60's (in the area to be treated). Plants are usually actively growing from late April to early June.

Retreatment. More than one treatment may be required for adequate control. Retreatment is usually required in succeeding years. Plants can regenerate each spring from seeds, spores, and underground rhizomes. These structures generally are not affected by aquatic herbicides. Also, new plants can sprout from seeds.

Dosage Calculations

Aquatic herbicides must be applied at labeled rates which were developed to provide effective, yet safe, weed control. Applying an excessive rate of a herbicide does not provide better weed control but does increase the cost and may harm the environment. Applying less than the recommended rate usually results in poor weed control. Some herbicide treatments, such as those for controlling emergent plants, are applied on the basis of the surface area to be treated. Others, such as those to control certain submersed weeds, are based on the volume of water to be treated. Read the label instructions carefully because mistakes in calculating treatment rates can be costly and dangerous.

Surface Area Treatment (in acres)

Calculate the amount of herbicide needed for a surface acre treatment using the following formula:

F = A × R

where:

  • F = Amount of formulated herbicide product
  • A = Area of the water surface in acres - The surface area of a rectangular body of water equals length in feet times width divided by 43,560 (the number of square feet in an acre).
  • R = Recommended rate of product per surface acre

Example:

How much product is needed (F) to treat a 500 ft x 100 foot pond (A) at the rate of 3.4 fluid ounces per acre (R).

(500 ft x 100 ft) = 50,000 sq ft/43,560 sq ft/acre = 1.15 acres

1.15 acres x 3.4 fl oz/acre = 3.9 fl oz of product


Acre-foot Treatment

Acre-foot dimensions

Many aquatic herbicides list their application rates in terms of the amount of product to use per acre-foot of water. An acre-foot of water is defined as 1 surface acre of water that is 1 foot deep. The number of acre-feet of water can be found by multiplying the number of surface acres times the average water depth.

The amount of herbicide needed for an acre-foot treatment is determined by the following formula:

F = A × D × R

where:

  • F = Amount of formulated herbicide product
  • A = Area of the water surface in acres
  • D = Average depth of the water in feet
  • R = Recommended rate of product per acrefoot

Example:

How much product is needed (F) to treat a 500 ft x 100 foot pond (A) that is 3 feet deep at the rate of 6 fluid ounces per acrefoot (R).

(500 ft x 100 ft) = 50,000 sq ft/43,560 sq ft/acre = 1.15 acres x 4 ft deep = 4.6 acrefeet.

4.6 acrefeet x 6 fl. oz. / acre foot = 27.6 fl oz of product


Parts Per Million (or Billion) Weight Treatment

The treatment rate of some aquatic herbicides may be listed as the final concentration of the chemical in the water on a parts per million weight (ppmw) basis.

Determine the amount of herbicide needed for a ppmw treatment by the following formula:

F = (A × D × CF × ECC) ÷ I

where:

  • F = Amount of formulated herbicide product
  • A = Area of the water surface in acres
  • D = Average depth of the water in feet
  • CF = 2.72 pounds per acre-foot (This is the conversion factor when total water volume is expressed on an acre-foot basis. 2.72 pounds of a herbicide per acre-foot of water is equal to 1 ppmw.)
  • ECC = Effective chemical concentration of the active ingredient of herbicide needed in water to control the weed
  • I = Total amount of active ingredient divided by the total amount of active and inert ingredients For liquid products, I = pounds of active ingredient per gallon. For dry products, I = percent active ingredient ÷ 100%.

Example:

How much of an 80% WP herbicide formulation is needed (F) to treat a 500 ft x 100 foot pond (A) that is 3 feet deep at the rate of 2 ppm (R).

(500 ft x 100 ft) = 50,000 sq ft/43,560 sq ft/acre = 1.15 acres x 3 ft deep = 3.45 acrefeet

3.45 acrefeet x 2.72 pounds/acrefoot = 9.38 pounds

9.38 pounds x 2 (ppm) = 18.76 pounds/0.8 (80% WP) = 23.5 lbs


Total Water Volume

The whole body of water from the surface to the bottom is treated OR only 1/4 to 1/3 of the water volume (based on surface area) at a time. Calculate the volume of the body of water and add chemical to obtain the required dilution.

The concentration of chemical needed to control aquatic plants is often stated in parts per million (ppm) or parts per billon (ppb). For example, if the toxic concentration for a particular plant is 2 ppm, then the chemical should be applied at the ratio of 2 parts of active ingredient to one million parts of water (2:1,000,000) in the area to be treated.

Calculate the acre-feet of the body of water to be treated. Multiply the surface acres by the average depth in feet.

An acre-foot of water weighs 2.7 million pounds (2,700,000). Multiply 2.7 x the ppm concentration wanted x acre-feet = pounds of active ingredient needed.


Example:

Calculate the number of pounds of active ingredient needed to treat a body of water containing 10 acre-feet at the rate of 0.5 ppm.

2.7 * 0.5 * 10 = 13.5 pounds of active ingredient


Application

Bottom soil surface

Herbicide applications may be made to the bottom soil of a drained pond, lake, or channel.

Floating and immersed weeds

can be killed with direct sprays on the foliage applied from a boat or the shore.

Submersed weeds and algae

can be treated using sprays or granular formulations. Sprays are applied as water surface treatments, particularly in shallow water. The herbicide is then dispersed by diffusion, thermal currents, and wave action. Good control depends upon good dispersion of the chemical.

Weed Control in Large Impoundments

Herbicides that work well in small bodies of water may perform poorly in large impoundments because of much greater water movement by thermal currents and wave action. In these cases, weed control may be improved by

  • using maximum recommended rates
  • treating relatively large areas at one time
  • apply when winds are at a minimum
  • use bottom treatments in deep water
  • select herbicides that are absorbed quickly by the plants

Weed Control in Limited-Flow Waterways

Flood drainage canals, sloughs, and drains are good examples of limited-flow waterways. Weed control methods in these systems are very similar to those for static water. Evaluate the possibility of contamination when planning herbicide use. In some areas, drainage water may flow onto crop land or into drinking water supplies.

Secondary and Environmental Effects of Aquatic Pesticide Applications

Incorrect applications of herbicides in water may pose serious hazards to humans, wildlife, fish, and desirable plant life. Select the correct herbicide and apply it at the proper rate. Follow all restrictions on the label. Water has many uses and herbicides will not always remain where they are applied.

Improper applications can kill fish directly or deplete the oxygen concentration excessively if the plants die too quickly. Decomposition of dead fish can contaminate downstream water supplies. Water may be unsuitable for humans, animals, or irrigation.

In Static Water - Ponds, Lakes, Reservoirs

Weed control may be unsatisfactory if application rates are too low in static water. Excessive application rates may kill fish, prevent use by livestock, or prohibit use for irrigation for an indefinite period. However, there should be little downstream effect because little or no outflow normally occurs.

In Limited-flow Water

Improper application rates could result in contamination of downstream water used by municipalities or communities for domestic water supplies. The hazardous condition would exist whether limited-flow water sources were treated with an application rate too low to accomplish a desired kill of vegetation or if the rate were excessive. Use of excessive rates might result in a fish kill that could affect downstream water supplies through bacteria from decay and decomposition of dead fish.

In Moving Water

Application of pesticides to moving waters may lead to at least temporary contamination of downstream domestic water supplies. In addition, non-target aquatic organisms may be affected.

Limited Area Application

Aquatic weeds may occur in the whole body of water as submersed weeds, or may appear to cover the whole surface of the water as floating weeds. Conversely, the same weeds or other pests may occur only in limited areas within a body of water, whether it is a static, limited-flow, or moving body of water. "Limited area application" implies the advantage of improved safety to aquatic species, specifically fish. If pesticides that are potentially toxic to the fish population are applied to a limited area, the fish population can move to untreated water areas to escape potential toxic effects. Also, a minimal amount of pesticide is applied. This tends to reduce the potential effect upon downstream environments in the event of spillover from the treated body of water.

Faulty Application

There are two major hazards involved in faulty application of pesticides:

(1) damage to non-target organisms

(2) unsatisfactory control.

For example, a granular formulation of an aquatic herbicide might work well in static water or limited-flow situations but it would be useless in fast moving water, All currently registered herbicides employed for aquatic weed control are rated as slightly toxic, or non-toxic to fish, birds, insects, and other aquatic organisms as long as proper application rates and techniques are employed. Pesticide labels should be carefully observed to ensure that the aquatic environment is not contaminated during pest control efforts.

Precautions

Unforeseen or unexpected conditions or circumstances may lead to less than satisfactory results even when best management practices are used. The applicator is always responsible for the effects of herbicide residues on livestock and crops, as well as problems that could arise from the drift or movement of herbicide from his/her property to that of others. Always read and follow carefully the instructions on the label.

Due to a federal court ruling, all applications of herbicides into or over waters of the U.S. fall under the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) National Pollution Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) as of 2011. The regulation reads, “You are required to obtain a permit if you discharge biological pesticide or chemical pesticide that leaves a residue in water when such applications are made into, over, or near waters of the United States.

Contact the Kentucky Energy and Environment Cabinet, Department for Environmental Protection, Division of Water, Surface Water Permits Branch for more information.

 

[return]

Practice Questions

 

1) Aquascreen is an example of ____________ control of aquatic plants.

  1. biological
  2. chemical
  3. mechanical
  4. cultural

2) Pond banks should be gently sloped so that water is less than 2 feet deep to prevent aquatic weed growth.

  1. True
  2. False

3) Large amounts of aquatic herbicides can move downstream from limited flow impoundments

  1. from sudden rainstorms during or immediately after an application
  2. through an overflow pipe
  3. over an emergency spillway

4) Drawdown is an example of __________ control of aquatic plants.

  1. biological
  2. chemical
  3. mechanical
  4. cultural

5) Aeration is an effective means of biological weed control.

  1. True
  2. False

6) Triploid grass carp can be used for aquatic weed control in Kentucky ponds because they _________________.

  1. are sterile
  2. multiply quickly
  3. eat large amounts of algae
  4. eat many mosquito larvae

7) Allowing livestock access to ponds and creeks is an effective means of biological weed control.

  1. True
  2. False

8) The number of acre-feet in a pond or lake is calculated by _______________.

  1. multiplying its surface area in acres by its depth
  2. multiplying its surface area in acres by its average depth
  3. one-half of its surface area by its depth
  4. dividing its volume by 43,560

9) The most important step in managing aquatic weeds is ______________.

  1. reading the product label carefully
  2. identifying the plant correctly
  3. calculating the dose correctly
  4. selecting the application equipment

10) _____________ is the best time to apply an aquatic herbicide.

  1. Early spring
  2. Late summer
  3. Fall
  4. Winter

11) If you must apply an aquatic herbicide in late summer, treat only a portion of the weed growth at a time.

  1. True
  2. False

12) A pond with a surface area of 1.5 acres and an average depth of 6 feet contains ______ acre-feet.

  1. 1.5
  2. 6
  3. 7.5
  4. 9

13) The number of acres of surface area of a pond or lake is calculated by multiplying ______________.

  1. Length (feet) x width (feet)
  2. Length (feet) x width (feet) x depth (feet)
  3. Length (feet) x width (feet) divided by 43,560
  4. Length (feet) x width (feet) x depth (feet) divided by 43,560

14) There are ___ pounds of active ingredient in 2 pounds of a 75% wettable powder formulation.

  1. 0.75
  2. 1
  3. 1.5
  4. 2

15) An acre-foot of water weighs _________ pounds.

  1. 2,700,000
  2. 272
  3. 2.72
  4. 1

16) Improper herbicide applications can kill fish directly or deplete the oxygen concentration if the plants die too quickly.

  1. True
  2. False

17) Weed control methods in moving water are very similar to those in limited-flow waterways.

  1. True
  2. False

18) The whole body of water should be treated with an aquatic herbicide even if the weed problem is present in only limited areas of the impoundment.

  1. True
  2. False

19) The two major hazards involving faulty application of aquatic herbicides are ________________________.

  1. damage to non-target organisms AND unsatisfactory control
  2. herbicide resistant weeds AND damage to non-target organisms
  3. unsatisfactory control AND excessive control costs
  4. pesticide drift AND herbicide resistant weeds

20) Which of the following is the most significant consideration when selecting an aquatic herbicide?

  1. Control may not be satisfactory
  2. The water to be treated may have multiple uses
  3. Most weeds are probably already resistant to herbicides
  4. The water temperature is between 65°F and 75°F

21) Excessively rapid kill of aquatic weeds may result in _____________.

  1. increased water temperature
  2. oxygen depletion
  3. an algal bloom
  4. decreased water temperature

22) Bottom treatments are primarily to control ___________ weeds.

  1. emersed
  2. algae
  3. floating
  4. submersed

 


Visits since 4/19/17:   Hit Counter by Digits

photo credits: banner image - Karan A. Rawlins, University of Georgia, Bugwood.org
website content by L. Townsend  website design by P. Dillon   copyright © 2016 University of Kentucky Department of Entomology
University of Kentucky College of Agriculture | S-225 Agricultural Science Center North, Lexington, KY 40546-0091 | 859.257.7450
An Equal Opportunity University | Last modified 04/21/2017